Edited by Toni Noe
Toni Noe' is a copywriter and editorial manager with over a decade of experience. Based in Nashville, she's passionate about helping students discover that turning your passion into a career isn't just a dream—it's possible with the right information and guidance.
Learn more about CVO’s Editorial Guidelines → Reviewed according toCVO’s Editorial Guidelines
The real challenge in online education lies in achieving a balance between your personal life at home or at work, and your studies. Indeed, it is critical that you choose the right format that suits your schedule and matches your learning style. This guide was created to help you make a confident decision with your unique situation in mind.
Key Takeaways
- Online Enrollment
- 54% of students took online courses in 2022
- Flexibility Preference
- 61% cite schedule flexibility as top priority
- Learning Outcomes
- Both formats show equivalent academic results
Resource Sections
1. Understanding the Basics
With synchronous learning, you can access lectures, readings, and assignments at any time within a set timeframe. Each program has different timeframes, but it is usually held on a weekly basis.
Here are a few practical examples to illustrate the asynchronous format:
• Watch pre-recorded lectures at 3 a.m., after your work shift ends.
• Read course materials, complete discussion posts, and write assignments during your work breaks.
• Submit assignments on Sunday evenings when you’re done with personal commitments.
Meanwhile, synchronous learning requires that you log in at specific times for live instruction with your instructor and classmates. You must also participate in the online activities, which often include recitations, discussions, and other live group activities.
Here are practical examples of how the synchronous format works.
1. Attend a live Zoom session every Tuesday at 7 p.m.
2. Participate in real-time virtual class discussions and other activities during scheduled class hours.
3. Conduct group work and live presentations with classmates during scheduled meeting times.
That the asynchronous format is “easier” is a misconception. The reality is that both formats require the same rigor and time commitment from you. In either of these formats, you are expected to read the course materials, watch the lectures, and submit your assignments on time.
Technology also plays a key role in both synchronous and asynchronous formats. You will learn to navigate a learning management system (LMS), such as Canvas, Moodle, or Blackboard, is the primary platform. You will also be using video conferencing platforms like Zoom, Google Meet, and Microsoft Teams.
Discussion boards and forums, cloud-based document sharing platforms, and collaboration tools are also common. Mobile apps, online assessment tools, and email and messaging tools are a must. You will have to be more tech-proficient to thrive in online programs.
Key Takeaway: Synchronous = live scheduled classes; asynchronous = learn anytime within deadlines.
2. Asynchronous Learning—Who It's Best For
The asynchronous learning format offers these core benefits:
You gain complete control over your study schedule.
You can study whenever and wherever it suits your schedule and lifestyle.
You can pause, rewind, and review the lecture content.
Your learning style and pace have a significant influence on your study schedule.
You can work around unpredictable travel schedules, urgent shift work commitments, and personal responsibilities such as caregiving.
You can skip a study day or two and catch up when your schedule permits.
You have more time to process complex information before responding, allowing you to structure your answers logically.
The asynchronous learning format is ideal for you if you belong to any of these groups:
• Working adults with variable schedules, such as healthcare workers on shifts
• Parents with caregiving responsibilities to small children or elderly parents
• Students in different time zones, including out-of-state and international students
• Self-motivated learners who can thrive without external structure
To take full advantage of asynchronous learning, you must set realistic expectations of what it is and what it’s not. Remember:
1. Self-discipline is a must. Your time management skills will be put to the test.
2. The learning environment can feel isolating. Without regular peer interaction, you are likely to experience a reduced sense of belonging, motivation, and engagement.
3. You can experience a higher cognitive load, managing your own pace. According to research, the limited immediate feedback, increased decision-making demands, and reduced real-time guidance can take a toll on your cognitive health.
Key Takeaway: Asynchronous works best if you need maximum flexibility and thrive with self-direction.
3. Synchronous Learning—Who It's Best For
By choosing the synchronous learning format, you enjoy these key benefits:
You experience real-time interaction with instructors and peers as you would in a traditional classroom.
Only this time, you are in the comfort of your own home.
You get immediate feedback on questions, which leads to more efficient learning.
Because of its built-in structure and accountability, you are more likely to adopt consistent study habits and stay on track.
You get a stronger sense of community and belonging.
You create meaningful interactions with your classmates and professors.
Research shows synchronous settings support students’ psychological needs for competence and relatedness.
When you feel connected and supported in real time, your confidence, engagement, and motivation increase.
If you identify with one of these groups, you’re most likely to thrive in a synchronous learning program:
• Students who need external structure to remain focused
• Students who learn best through real-time discussion and collaboration
• Learners who struggle with and want to overcome procrastination
• Students in fields that require real-time practice, such as giving presentations and honing clinical skills
Being aware and learning to overcome the challenges of synchronous learning is vital to your success as a student:
1. Scheduling flexibility is a must to promptly attend set class times.
2. Technical issues can disrupt participation. Internet issues and equipment problems are not uncommon.
3. Time zone differences can be a real challenge. It requires a careful selection of the right synchronous learning program within your time zone, or that which is offered by regional or local providers.
4. Research indicates that, owing to multitasking demands, synchronous students experience a higher cognitive load during live sessions.
Key Takeaway: Synchronous works best if you need structure, accountability, and real-time interaction.
4. Comparing The Formats Side By Side
Take a look at the various aspects that make synchronous and asynchronous learning different—and determine which format is best suited to your needs.
Flexibility:
Asynchronous: Maximum flexibility, meaning you can attend at 2 p.m. or 2 a.m., whichever fits your learning style and schedule.
Synchronous: Limited flexibility—you must attend scheduled sessions.
Interaction:
Asynchronous: Delayed interaction through discussion boards
Synchronous: Real-time discussions and immediate Q&A and feedback
Accountability:
Asynchronous: Self-imposed deadlines entail a lot of discipline
Synchronous: Built-in accountability through attendance in scheduled lessons
Learning Pace:
Asynchronous: Control your pace and review materials repeatedly
Synchronous: Adhere to the fixed pace set by the instructor
Community:
Asynchronous: Requires more effort to build connections
Synchronous: Encourages natural peer relationships
Technology Requirements:
Asynchronous: Reliable internet for downloading and streaming
Synchronous: Strong internet + webcam and microphone
Based on these comparisons, which is the better choice? The answer is neither, because your choice will be based on your lifestyle, learning style, and goals.
In making your decision, also consider this key finding in research: A meta-analysis found that asynchronous learning is slightly more effective for knowledge acquisition. Emphasis must be made, however, that the effect size was trivial. It means both formats work when you’re engaged.
Key Takeaway: Neither format is universally "better"—the right choice depends on your life and learning style.
5. The Hybrid/Blended Option
Several online programs offer the hybrid or blended option. This option features a best-of-both-worlds approach: combining the elements of asynchronous and synchronous learning.
Hybrid/blended courses typically include these elements:
• Pre-recorded lectures to watch on your schedule and pace
• Weekly live discussion sessions and scheduled meetings
• Asynchronous assignments that require individual submissions, combined with synchronous group projects or projects graded as a group
• Online quizzes or polls that you can complete in your own time, combined with live review sessions for feedback or to discuss results
• Participation in discussion boards paired with real-time Q&A with professors
Studies highlight the benefits of the hybrid or blended options:
• Students in blended courses performed better than those in fully online or fully traditional courses, according to a 2010 Department of Education study.
• Hybrid models allow flexibility while maintaining community. You can study at your own time and pace, thanks to asynchronous courses. At the same time, you still create and sustain connections, thanks to synchronous sessions.
The terminology is where it gets tricky. Here’s what you need to know:
Hybrid/Blended
Mix of online and in-person sessions OR mix of asynchronous and synchronous classes
HyFlex
Each week, students choose to either attend live or watch recordings
A word of caution: Hybrid courses require students to manage both types of learning. Attending a hybrid program can be more demanding than committing to one format.
You must learn to quickly switch between formats, which requires you to adapt to both. You may also have to meet multiple deadlines, which calls for better time management and organization skills.
Key Takeaway: Hybrid courses combine both formats, offering flexibility with built-in interaction.
6. Self-Assessment—Which Format Fits You?
Choosing the best format that truly works for you starts with being honest about yourself. It’s crucial to assess your level of commitment, preferences, and needs to make the right decision.
Questions to Ask Yourself:
Schedule & Commitments:
• Does your job involve rotating shifts and an unpredictable schedule?
If yes, the asynchronous format is better.
• Can you fully commit to attending class at the same time each week?
If yes, go for the synchronous format.
• Are you in a different time zone than your school?
If yes, consider the asynchronous format.
Learning Preferences:
• Which allows you to learn better: live discussion or independent study?
Go for the synchronous option if you prefer live discussions. Prioritize the asynchronous format if you like self-paced study more.
• Would you rather have an immediate answer to your questions than an email response?
If you prefer the former, the synchronous option is ideal.
• Are you comfortable moving through any course material at your own pace?
Choose the asynchronous format if you are.
Self-Discipline:
• Do you consider yourself a natural self-starter, or do you learn better with external deadlines?
If you’re the latter, go for the synchronous option.
• Do you procrastinate when no one is watching?
Consider the synchronous format to encourage structure.
• Can you create your own study schedule and stick to it?
If you answered yes, your best bet is the asynchronous format.
Connection Needs:
• Is building relationships with your classmates important to you?
Pick the synchronous option if this matters to you.
• Does learning alone make you feel isolated?
If it does, choose the synchronous option because it supports connectedness.
• Will a regular face-to-face (virtual) instructor contact benefit you more?
Again, choose the synchronous option if you learn better with actual engagement.
Key Takeaway: Honest self-reflection about your schedule, learning style, and discipline is essential.
HowTo: Assess Your Best Learning Format
-
Map Your Existing Schedule #Write down every fixed commitment in your week—work hours, family obligations, appointments. Identify your genuinely available time blocks.
-
Identify Your Peak Learning Times #When are you most alert and focused? Morning? Late evening? Note whether these times are consistent or variable.
-
Reflect on Past Learning Experiences #Think about times you learned successfully. Did structure help or hinder you? Did you thrive with deadlines or flexibility?
-
Match Findings to Format #If your available time is scattered and you’re self-disciplined, asynchronous may work. If you have consistent availability and need accountability, synchronous may be better.
7. Strategies for Success in Either Format
It pays to learn the risks and rewards of synchronous and asynchronous learning from the get-go. Here are actionable strategies to make either format work in your favor:
For Asynchronous Learners:
1. Develop and stick to a study routine even without required attendance.
2. Set personal deadlines before meeting actual deadlines.
3. Actively participate in discussion boards. Consistently engage in conversations instead of simply posting and disappearing.
4. Reach out to instructors proactively. Don’t ask for help only when you’re already struggling.
5. Rewatch lectures strategically to grasp difficult concepts.
For Synchronous Learners:
1. Test your technology and equipment before the first class to avoid disruptions.
2. Treat class time as sacred. Minimize distractions and keep focused on your lessons.
3. Prepare your questions in advance. Doing this allows you to engage actively and maximize live interaction.
4. Use chat features for active engagement during sessions.
5. Record the sessions (if permitted) for you to review later.
For Both Formats:
1. Communicate with your instructors early and often. Ask questions to learn and to build a valuable academic relationship.
2. Connect with your classmates. Engage with your fellow learners to build peer support.
3. Create a dedicated study space that allows you to focus. You must have your own spot that is free 4. from distractions.
4. Build in breaks to avoid burnout. Schedule your breaks properly to manage stress and enhance focus.
5. Use campus resources to your advantage. Online students like you have access to tutoring, advising services, and writing centers.
Key Takeaway: Your success depends more on your approach than the format you choose.
8. Questions to Ask Before Enrolling
When choosing between synchronous and asynchronous learning, learn everything there is to about the program. You must ask the admissions counselor or program coordinator the right questions. Take a look at this checklist:
About Format:
• What percentage of the online program is offered as synchronous vs. asynchronous format?
• Are the synchronous sessions recorded for later viewing?
• On what days and times are synchronous sessions typically held?
• Is there an option to complete the entire program asynchronously if needed?
About Technology:
• What learning management system does the online learning program use?
• What are the technical requirements of the online program in terms of internet speed, webcam, and software?
• What type and level of technical support is available to online students?
About Interaction:
• What platform is used for interacting with instructors in asynchronous courses?
• What’s the typical response time I can expect for instructor feedback?
• Are there opportunities to engage with other online students?
About Flexibility:
What happens if an online student misses a synchronous session?
Are online students allowed to take a lighter course load during busy seasons at work?
Is there flexibility in the setting of assignment deadlines?
About Support:
• What support services are offered to online students?
• Do online learners have an academic advisor?
• Is there a way for online students to access tutoring or writing help?
Key Takeaway: Get specifics from schools before committing—"online" doesn't tell you enough.
